r/etiquette • u/Visual_Media6735 • 15d ago
Is it appropriate to ask fairly distant relatives to contribute toward a business-class or premium-economy upgrade for a parent's birthday trip?
My spouse recently received a group text from a cousin regarding the cousin's mother's 75th birthday.
The cousin explained that she is planning to take her mother to Japan. She wants to book her mother in business class or premium economy for the long-haul flight, either one way or round trip depending on the cost.
She then invited extended family members to contribute any amount they wanted toward the upgraded airfare. She specifically said there was no obligation to contribute and that any amount would be appreciated.
For some context:
- We are extended family, but we aren't particularly close. We probably see her once every year or two, usually at larger family gatherings.
- Her mother is also extended family rather than someone we have a particularly close personal relationship with.
- This isn't a situation involving financial hardship or an emergency. They appear financially stable and the Japan trip is already something the cousin intends to take with her mother.
- The money being requested isn't to make the trip possible. It's specifically to help pay for a premium-economy or business-class upgrade as a birthday surprise.
My spouse and I had different initial reactions to the message, so I'm curious about the general etiquette here.
I completely understand siblings, children, grandchildren, or very close family members deciding together to pool money for a milestone birthday gift.
What felt unusual to me was reaching out to more distant relatives and asking them to financially participate in a fairly expensive luxury gift that had already been chosen by the person organizing it.
At the same time, the message was polite and clearly said there was no obligation, so perhaps this is becoming normal for group gifts.
Would you consider this a perfectly reasonable invitation to participate in a group gift, somewhat tacky but harmless, or inappropriate etiquette?
I'm genuinely interested in how others would perceive the request rather than whether we personally should contribute.