I (30F) and my boyfriend TJ (35M) have been together for 3 years, and friends for 8. His best friend Ian (35M), has been married to his wife Becca(34F) for two years, together 8. I met Ian and Becca 2.5 years ago.
When we first met, we got along relatively well, and would often plan group outings to see live music or grab a drink and hangout. The boys are best friends after all(+20 years), and even though Becca and I didn’t mesh perfectly, we had fun overall and it was chill.
However, there’s been a recent shift in our dynamic, and it came to a head when Becca expressed her decision to cut off TJ and I.
Apparently, she has been feeling resentful towards us for the past few months, and decided to tell my boyfriend the day before yesterday that she was done with us and done trying to be friends.
To give some context, TJ, Ian, and I all share the same friend group, so when the 4 of us are together, the 3 of us tend to get along and converse a little easier. Also, TJ and Ian are in a band together, with my boyfriend TJ being the main drive behind it. I help manage their social media stuff like IG and make their album art for them.
Ian and Becca are a little bit of a mismatched couple. They don’t have a lot of similar interests, and Ian has expressed some sadness over it but overall says he loves that they’re different from each other.
Becca herself is a sweet girl and nice enough, but if I’m being completely honestly, she isn’t someone I would naturally be friends with if it wasn’t for our proximity in relationships (our partners being basically brothers.) We don’t have a lot in common, and the things we prioritize in our lives are very different. That being said, I didn’t think it’d be an issue until this past year.
The last few times we’ve seen Becca, I could sense something was off. It felt like every time TJ and I came to visit, she would hide in her room and stay inside, or just leave for the day while the guys had band practice and we all hung out in the garage. She even snapped at me during one of our visit when I asked if their dog was 2 yet, and corrected me saying she was 22 months old. It wasn’t hard to tell something was wrong, and in return I felt myself getting frustrated. I even had a long and vulnerable conversation with TJ 2 months ago about how I know I’m a little standoffish and harsh, and that I needed some space to allow myself to be able to hangout again with feeling off around her. I know how much TJ and Ian mean to each other, so I wanted to be able to put my feelings aside and be more grounded to make things less awkward. He agreed and said it was probably for the best, being he feels she has been off towards him as well lately.
So, the day before yesterday, TJ heads to band practice without me. The day went normal until TJ goes to leave and Ian lets him know that Becca won’t be coming out to tell him goodbye. TJ was taken aback by that, and being a very direct and open communicator, told Ian to go get her so they could talk about what’s going on before he left. Ian did, and things got heated.
According to Becca, she is done with TJ and I because we don’t include her, she’s tired of being disrespected in her home, and she doesn’t want to be fake anymore. She states that we come over and we play with her dog and her cats, but that we don’t include her. She went on to say that she thinks I’m disrespectful to her by not engaging with her enough, not being more grateful for a gift she gave me, and for refusing to eat the food she cooked for us in her home the last time we visited. She stated more things, but ultimately the message I got was that she thinks that I haven’t tried as hard as her to build a relationship, that TJ and I don’t include her, and that she’s straight up done with me and, by partnership, TJ.
TJ defended me, letting her know that we feel like she doesn’t even want us around, and that she doesn’t include herself enough. When in conversation, TJ told her that I just try a little more to be present in it, and that I do have more similar interests with him and Ian so it’s easier. The gift was a bouquet of fake flowers she had arranged and given to me closing night of a show where my character has a full mental b and ends it. She said that she didn’t even want to go to the show, and that I should’ve been more grateful for the time she had spent making the bouquet. TJ told her I said a quick thank you as I was honestly extremely burnt out and mentally drained after my performance(v true). The food thing he explained was because I’m a vegetarian, and they had made carne asada tacos for dinner. She got mad and yelled at him why didn’t I say something then, but TJ reminded her that I have told them multiple times in the past 2 years, and that it’s tiring for me to have to constantly tell people something a friend would make note of. She then went on to say that I have “heavy blood”(Mexican slang) and that she just doesn’t want me around.
Ian was crying, and it was basically Becca and TJ arguing with each other. TJ said he was finally able to compose himself and got the conversation on the track of how to fix this. He told Becca that we’re all going to get past this and that he does love and care about her as a person, not just as his best friend’s wife. Becca took it well he said, and seems like she was able to hear him out at least a bit. He gave her a long hug, Ian a hug, and came home.
TJ told me everything, and we had a long discussion about how we will be moving to fix this, but also decided to allow our self some space to process how we’re feeling about it all. TJ feels like a lot of Becca’s hurt feelings are her projecting onto us, using us as an excuse to avoid other problems in her life/marriage, and I agree but it is what it is. We both want to maintain our relationship with Ian, so we intend to do what is needed to make that happen.
As for now though, I’m upset and angry and feeling guilty. I’m upset that in the moment where her and I felt similar emotions, I decided to take a step back and try and figure out how I can fix this, and she decided to blow it all up. I’m angry at the “heavy blood” comment, and feel like she’s using me as a scapegoat for her insecurities. I’m angry she said she doesn’t want to be fake anymore, implying she’s been fake for a while and has to be seen as a nice person rather than being honest. And I feel guilty that my boyfriend and Ian are having to deal with this situation all together, and that Ian was crying over it.
What makes me the most upset is that all of this could have been avoided if Becca had just taken the time to tell lan that she was feeling isolated or neglected, or if Ian would just consider her more as his wife in the first place, and not make that have to be on us as the guest/friends. TJ agrees that this all got taken too far and that they should’ve had a conversation about her feelings of animosity before it got to this point (but we’re here now and gonna work on it.)
Ultimately, I’m a little lost, hurt, and confused. I’m not sure what expectations she had for her and I as far as friendship goes, and I don’t know where to go from here. I’m trying my best to hold space for her and her feelings, while honoring mine as well.
If anyone has any advice on how to process a situation like this and begin reconciliation I’d be extremely grateful. Where would you begin?
Thank you for reading <3
(all names changed for privacy)