(TW: acephobia)
(This involves religion in relation to my personal experiences in relation to my asexuality and to provide context. I, in no way, mean to promote my faith, proselytize, or claim that people of my faith are oppressed. I do not care what other people believe, (as long as it is not hateful or promoting violence/otherwise harm) my religious beliefs are just what work for me. I do not expect for anyone to need to change their lives for my personal beliefs.)
I am asexual. This is something I only came to understand about two years ago, although I always knew I found those sorts of things strange and entirely unappealing.
I am also a diocesan Roman Catholic priest. (This means I work in a parish)
I have spoken to so many people that I could not think of a proper estimate of how many have spoken to me about lust before other than "a lot". Sex and lust is an incredibly common subject. I am regularly asked questions about, requested to give advice on, and counselling on this. Sins of lust are one of the most common that come up in confession.
Often the question comes up around my own experiences. This is very personal but I believe that it makes sense, often they want to know if this is something that I have also struggled with and how I deal with it. However, I don't have any. I have never wanted to commit any sort of sexual act, I do not find the idea of masturabation appealing.
Especially for men, there is a strong expectation for us to be inherently deeply sexual creatures. From my personal experience, the mere concept of this potentially not being the case is downright unthinkable to many.
When I am asked these things, and believe the question is relevant, I have come to always feel the need to give a whole preamble about how "everyone is different and we all struggle/are tempted by different things/in different ways" all "we all have our own cross to bear and this is different" etc. before I finally answer that I don't personally struggle with these things and that I am "not much of a sexual person at all”.
I know that, regardless of my preamble, it is more than likely that I will be assumed to be less than truthful. I have come to learn that priests are both expected to be not sexual people while at the same time, there is also that underlying assumption and stereotype that all of us struggle with lust. We are men, therefore are inherently deeply sexual and, as we cannot get married, there is no outlet for all that presumed sexual energy, all while this struggle is all the more taboo due to the nature of the vocation. When the honest answer is that I do not struggle with this at all, not even just very little, it could be seen as me trying to cover up these taboo temptations I must have.
However, I will still answer them all the same regardless of if they believe me or not. It is not like I will lie to them.
Even with other LGBTQ people, both Catholic and not, I have been confronted with the questions and direct, hard-line accusations before that this is not the reality of my situation. I must be lying to them or even myself to cover up guilt. I am trying to sound virtuous and “holier than thou”. Or maybe I am sexually repressed from my religion or from some sort of previous religious trauma I must have apparently suffered.
I have even been told that asexuality does not exist by LGBTQ+ people. I assumed that they wouldn't think it wasn't even real, but that apparently isn't the case.
Asexuality overall often seems to be denied by many, I just expected for other LGBTQ+ people to get it more. Regardless of who It comes from It is so invalidating, disheartening, and frustrating. It is so hurtful and I do not understand why it would be impossible for someone to want/like sex less or not at all. It is just one aspect of life, why does it matter if someone does not engage in it? It is especially confusing and hurtful to me when someone is very open and accepting of people with different sexualities, preferences, etc then apparently that extends only until someone's preference is nothing.
While how I was raised undoubtedly strongly impacts my world view and how I live my life to one extent or another, I do not believe I am asexual because of religious trauma. I don't believe I have religious trauma, (at least any that contributes to me being asexual in of itself.) I grew up in a very religious household and community, but religion was always an incredibly positive thing in my life. I always loved going to church/volunteering with/etc. Going to God and physically going to church was always something that felt safe and welcoming to me, especially during times when I did not feel that way about other places. Even our church’s priest growing up is an amazing man who has had an incredibly positive impact on me, I genuinely believe he saved my life. It was never something that made me feel overly guilty, like a bad person, fearful, or unworthy.
I wasn’t raised to believe that sex was evil and impure, nor that you are a bad tainted person if you have sex outside of marriage. Chastity was taught but in a way that sex was a special sacred thing made only for within a marriage. So it was presented by the positive angle, not a negative one and without badness being connected to sex. I grew up in a conservative community, but it wasn't openly demonized or the like, although I do suppose it wasn't really openly talked about much at all ever.
I have learned that I was definitely quite sheltered and there was a lot I didn't learn until I was an adult, (to a bit of an embarrassing extent sometimes, if I am being honest) although I think a great deal of it I believe was because I am dense to that sort of thing and have trouble picking it up.
Even if I don't think it would be the case that me being asexual would be because of anything like that, even if I had it. I never found it appealing since I even learned what it was. Wouldn't there still be at least some underlying desire or just something at the same time? I just don't want to flat out. The idea of never having sex in my life is great. I am not bothered by the idea of never being in a relationship at all. (as Solaire of Astoria isn't real. Lol) I do not mourn that at all.
I understand the immediate aversion based on my relation to religion and being a religious leader. It just still hurts my feelings even if I understand and do not blame anyone.
I feel like I do not belong anywhere.
My parish is in a conservative area with a mainly aging population. If I mention the word “asexual” directly off the bat I am concerned with creating an immediate lack of credibility due to prejudice towards this sort of terminology. I need to round about the word and explain what it is to warm them up before name dropping if the subject becomes relevant. Even before I do so I feel like they don't believe me.
If I go in LGBTQ+ spaces (at least online, I live in a very rural area and have little free time.) then I feel like I don't belong there either. Part of this is undoubtedly is just not anxiety but I have had negative experiences, even if I am not the one bringing up any of these things I will inevitably asked what I do for a living. It is upsetting that I feel like I can’t talk about my life without concern of potentially hurting others or making them uncomfortable due to my religion being inseparable from talking about it at all outside of my other random hobbies and interests. I love doing that but I still have to keep out the vast majority of what I do and my own life experiences. (Again, not about subjects regarding theology or proselytizing, just in context of those experiences, what I do during the day, etc.)
This is certainly mainly anxiety but I also have this feeling that I am not educated enough or I am missing something that everyone else knows that I don’t. I even feel weird saying that I am asexual, for whatever reason it feels like I am armchair diagnosing myself and that I am unqualified to decide that. I know that it is obviously not how it works but it still feels like that even though I know I am. I have done a lot of research, I genuinely want to know about other people and their lives and struggles, but I feel like I always don’t have enough. I am so bad with picking up common vernacular and it at least feels like terms are evolving and new ones come up so quickly that I can’t keep up. I already have to google slang while casually messaging and the like with even people my own age, and this feels so much harder because then sometimes it will lead to a new term or concept I don’t know so then I have to look into that to understand it, but then that leads to another term or concept I don’t know, and so on. I have asked for advice on this from people I know and even on reddit before that have given me excellent resources, but I still feel left behind.
I do not hold it against any of the LGBTQ+ people that they would be wary of me, especially due to my faith and vocation. LGBTQ+ people and both religion and religious people do not have a good track record to say the absolute least. So many of them have horrible experiences, even those that are not LGBTQ+. Religious trauma is horrifyingly common.
I am also not trying to declare that I am being victimised and somehow Christians are oppressed by the mean alphabet mafia here in the West, especially where I live in a majority Christian, and majority Catholic overall county. I know that isn't the case at all.
Talking about sexuality or romance in regards to myself is incredibly difficult for me. I am incredibly uncomfortable with just the idea of other people might think about what I may or may not be into at all. It is difficult for me to explain but it feels almost violating in a way.
If it actually comes to me talking about it then I am already in this vulnerable situation, then someone tells you “Nah, mate. That's just not real, you're lying to either me or yourself.” feels so bad.
I do not understand the idea that someone knows someone else's preferences better than them. Why would some say that someone else is just incorrect about their own personal preferences?
I am pretty sure I think that sex is yucky and I would rather just sit here, be celibate, and crush on fictional men. I'm sorry, I didn't realise I had to run that by the council to find out if I actually feel that way or if I am lying to myself and/or them.
Even now as I write this I am going in with the assumption that I will be assumed to be lying, mistaken, acting a victim (I know I am in an incredibly privileged position, I am not trying to claim I am in any way oppressed),, or trying to shove my religion in people's faces (I only mention it so heavily in this post as it is the main aspect of the post). I promise I am not doing those things.
I posted something with similarities to this before and I got a comment that I was playing 4d chess, making it up to try to promote my faith by making this story up so people then feel bad for me. I know I shouldn't be bothered by comments on the internet but it is still something I think about. I would keep out the aspects about religion but it is intrinsically tied to what I am trying to say.
I worry that I am overdoing it with all my disclaimers/clarifications even in this post, but I worry if I do not include them then it will be misinterpreted. I'm just worried.
If anyone has advice on any of this or similar experiences I would greatly appreciate them. Ideas for different angles on how to explain asexuality, how to respectfully bring it up with other LGBTQ+ people, resources or advice on my issues with staying updated with LGBTQ+ subjects would also be amazing.
Unfortunately I believe that there is not much I can actively do right now to truly get passed this. We can work to educatie, and normalize, and raise awareness of asexuality, and we should. But reasonably it is still a very long term goal. The preconceptions that also have to do with other greater societal issues are still there.
Especially with the state of the western world right now. Society is only becoming more extremely polarised. Hatred and discrimination overall is openly expressed and ruled on. Hatred against LGBTQ+ people has also greatly heightened and many rights walked back and stripped away. Religious extremism, particularly Christian extremism, is at a horrifying high, in the spotlight, and playing a large role in actual action against already discriminated against people. Anyone can come to change and understand, but it is still so much to get through.
It's just so rough. I wish I could grab someone by the shoulders, shake them while yelling whatever it is they should get through their head and just get it.