Discussion Looking for feedback: using 1/1 NFTs as certificates of authenticity for physical pieces I'm giving away free
I've been drawing for decades, and I'm planning to give away physical pieces with an NFT attached to each one. Before I commit my own money, I'd like people who know this space to tell me whether I'm building on solid ground or on something that peaked in 2021.
How it works:
- Each piece is a real object. Some are drawings I made, some are things I carried through a stretch of my life that's part of the project.
- Each one gets a 1/1 ERC-721 token on Base, minted from my own contract through Manifold, as its certificate of authenticity. An NFC sticker on the object points to the token on a block explorer.
- I send USDC from my own savings to the recipient's wallet along with the token, plus a few dollars of ETH for gas, so it costs them nothing.
- Nobody buys anything. No mint, no coin, no fractions, no promised returns.
- Recipients use Base App with a passkey, so people who've never touched crypto don't have to manage a seed phrase. I do a small test send before every hand-off.
- Family first, then friends, then strangers. In person when I can, over video call and tracked mail when I can't.
Why I'm doing it: images are cheap now, but an object a specific person actually made or lived with can't be generated, and neither can a public record of it that nobody can quietly edit. That seems closer to what ERC-721 was written for (the original EIP lists physical property first and calls the tokens deeds) than to what the profile-picture boom turned it into.
My questions:
- Is Base a sound choice for something meant to last decades, or would you mint on mainnet?
- For people who've never owned crypto, where does onboarding actually break?
- Does "free NFT with money attached" read as a scam to you? Spam airdrops are everywhere, and I want this to look obviously different from those.
- Is there a reason this is a bad idea that I'm not seeing?
I'm not selling anything and won't post links. If anyone wants to pick apart the full step-by-step, I'm happy to paste it in the comments.
