r/HonestHotTakes • u/MechaTudor8574 • 4h ago
serious hot take Science has become toxic
I can't really explain the situation in full because it is too complicated, but briefly, I have a master's degree in physics and I have been a hobbyist in the subject ever since I graduated while I worked in IT. Usually it was in the evenings but sometimes I would be reading some physics in my lunch break. Sometimes it was when I didn't have a lot going on that day. Anyway, the point is, I managed to find time for this and although I didn't spend a few extra years doing a PhD, I have spent 15 years studying it in my spare time and working on my own research project.
And I think I have some good ideas. I'm not a crackpot, I had a core knowledge of the subject from university and I greatly expanded this in the years since and worked out some of my own ideas. Yes, it's unusual, but there are 8 billion people on planet; you do get some strange people doing interesting things.
Well, in my naivety, I thought I was going to find people legitimately interested in my ideas. Instead I found a bunch of apes jumping up and down, throwing shit.
On most subreddits and forums you are banned immediately for even mentioning a personal theory. I was perma-banned for "spam" from Physics Forums, within 5 minutes of first posting, just for mentioning I had a theory.
It is no exaggeration to say that multiple times now, people on physics subreddits actually have tried to bully me when I started a thead asking for advice, or to vent about the difficult process. Most of the comments were contained insults and some people actually showed a desire to humiliate; many comments falsely accused me of generating a paper with AI, even though there was no basis for this claim at all; in fact it is the most un-AI-like physics paper you could imagine.
All of this and they didn't even know the title or the abstract of my paper, let alone the content.
They would say that I'm the delusional one. I would say that they are delusional for vastly overestimating themselves relative to me. It is like they think their PhD sheepskin makes them superior mortals.
I seem to remember the days when scientists were really nice people. What has happened? The people who were going after me, come across like insecure incels. Even if I was a crackpot, what harm was I doing? Nobody is going to be harmed by a quantum mechanics interpretation or a proto-quantum-gravity theory. The fact that the reaction was so out of proportion, suggests that it struck a nerve and this was really an ego thing with them.
This all makes me sad, because this project was a private quest of mine for 15 years, which occupied so much of my time. And the thanks I get is vile abuse, credentialism, and actual attempts to belittle and bully. I've got to believe that eventually I will meet some people who at least hear what I have to say. But there are just so many really nasty, insecure, power-hungry, egocentric, delusional, self-serving people out there, and from what I'm seeing, scientists are some of the worst ones for it.