I've now played every private course in the RDU area at least twice, so I thought I'd put together my rankings. Just meant to be fun and spur some debate. I think the top 3 and bottom 3 are pretty obvious, but there's a lot of gray area in between. Don't just claim a course deserves to be higher; you need to also tell us who's being moved down.
For some context, I'm a 3.4 handicap live in Apex and play out of a private club in the Sandhills. I really value great conditions and a fun layout.
1. Raleigh Country Club
In my opinion, far and away the best club in the RDU area. Awesome restoration; golf as it should be. Truly the only course in the area that could host a high-level men’s championship.
Cons: You may get shot driving to the club.
2. Old Chatham
Quiet, secluded, impeccably conditioned. Feels like an escape, golf heaven. Incredible practice facilities.
Cons: From start to finish, a really solid course, but I think it lacks that memorable signature hole or tough stretch of holes.
3. Treyburn Country Club
Great routing, really fun course. Very good pace of play, and probably the best greens I’ve played in the area.
Cons: In the middle of nowhere (but that does result in a quick round).
4. North Ridge Country Club
Lakes course is fantastic, a good mix of fun and reachable par 5s and long par 3s. The Oaks course is pretty average, but having 36 holes on site is a plus. Both courses are well conditioned. The clubhouse has it all.
Cons: Really busy club; seems a bit impersonal. Practice facilities are ok, but not great.
5. Governors Club
Good variety among the Lakes, Foothills, and Mountain courses. Good views, well conditioned. All three 9’s are demanding in their own way.
Cons: Personal choice, but I think 27 holes is just weird. I hate the multiple routings. Find space for another 9, or just make an incredible 18 holes.
6. Hope Valley
A lot like Raleigh CC, feels historic being on site. The history oozes out of this place. Devilish greens, amongst the fastest I’ve played.
Cons: Practice facilities for a club of this caliber are subpar. Downhill range and no real short game area. Tough walk, very hilly.
7. Hasentree Club
Tough track, a good test for golfers of all skill levels. This could be a pro or con depending on personal preference, but I think it has a high-end resort type of feel. Great clubhouse, practice facilities, and dining options. Great mix of holes, a few fun drivable par 4s.
Cons: Not walkable at all; the neighborhood feels a little too close to the golf course in parts.
8. Prestonwood Country Club
There are 18 good holes on site; it’s just too bad they are spread out amongst 54 holes. Big club, but well run and can handle the huge membership. As you would expect, great conditioning.
Cons: Feels built for volume, and none of the courses stand out as exceptional.
9. The Club at Wakefield
Part of the McConnell Network. Tough track, probably too tough for most. But a great challenge for the low handicap players. Love that they have a Family 9; great spot for kids to learn the game without clogging up the championship course. Great range.
Cons: Tight and hilly, making for a tough walk. The course feels a bit forced in spots.
10. The 12 Oaks Club
The best Tiff Eagle greens I’ve played in the area. Good golfers. Unforgiving course; it’ll make you better or make you quit. Awesome practice facilities. For the family, it has a similar resort feel to Hasentree.
Cons: The par five 7th is one of the worst holes ever designed. Atrocious. The neighborhood encroaches on the golf course a little too much.
11. Croasdaile Country Club
The best range on the list. Not too hard, not too easy, fun layout that’s very walkable. Membership seems to skew younger.
Cons: Bent grass greens; they are good, but in this area, why are clubs holding on?
12. Carolina Country Club
Location, location, location. Really good instructors teach out of here. Interesting and hilly terrain.
Cons: Don’t tell the blue hairs and trust fund babies, but Carolina Country Club in South Carolina is much better. This course gets by on legacy and perceived prestige rather than being a great course.
13. Briercreek Country Club
Good risk-reward holes. Overall a fun layout with decent conditioning. The 18th is one of the better finishing holes in the area.
Cons: I really hate that part of town. The Champions Bermuda greens are great, but the rest of the course can be hit or miss with the conditioning.
14. MacGregor Downs
Much like Carolina, a prime location. I enjoy the old-school rustic clubhouse overlooking the lake and controversial 18th hole.
Cons: Greens always sub-par. Ok layout, but nothing memorable. Even in a drought, the course can be wet.
15. Chapel Hill Country Club
Four or five really solid and fun holes on the back 9. Good conditioning.
Cons: Strange clubhouse. The back 9 is good, but it can be underwater a lot. Front 9 is repetitive and boring.
16. Bentwinds Country Club
Very walkable. Conditions are on par with any course on this list. New Bermuda greens are good, albeit a little soft.
Cons: Arguably the worst course on the list. Typical late 70’s early 80’s design that squeezes a golf course into a neighborhood. Doglegs for days! Definitively the worst practice facilities on the list. Internal OB!
17. Devils Ridge Good value, good mix of holes. A lot of elevation changes. Free popcorn in the clubhouse.
Cons: Conditioning is average at best, especially the bentgrass greens that take a beating from members. Feels more like a semi-private experience than a private club.