r/BeAmazed • • Aug 11 '26

Miscellaneous / Others South Korea is closing the dog meat industry.

Post image
25.3k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

53

u/Throw-away10111 Aug 11 '26

I'm probably going to get dragged but honestly I agree. People are congratulating this like chickens, cows and pigs aren't treated the same way. Why was anything they did different? Because it's a dog?

13

u/snek-jazz Aug 11 '26

It's a decision based on practicality/feelings rather than morals.

7

u/quite_certain Aug 11 '26

All the comments in this thread provide so much support for ethical emotivism

6

u/snek-jazz Aug 11 '26

ethical emotivism

That term was new to me, but indeed seems to be what I'm talking about

8

u/Omal15 Aug 11 '26

Yeah, the distinction that is made is completely arbitrary. The same people in this thread who would be outraged at seeing dog farms are more than happy to support the industry that subjects those other animals to the same fate

1

u/IYuShinoda Aug 12 '26

Well the dog is the man's best friend

-1

u/ThatDuude_ Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26

Because dogs are household animals, the saying is "dogs are a mans' best friend" not "cows/pigs/chickens are a mans' best friend". We've bred dogs to obey us and help us hunt and give us comfort, we've bred cows/chickens/pigs as animals to eat. They (farm animals) can be highly intelligent animals but that's just how it works. I personally wouldn't slaughter them (farm animals) but l love to eat, so...

9

u/Lopsided_Tiger_0296 Aug 11 '26

In Korea owning dogs as pets is recent thing. They mostly viewed dogs similarly to cows and pigs being raised for food rather than a family member. Just because it’s not your way of seeing it doesn’t make it wrong

-1

u/ThatDuude_ Aug 11 '26

Respectfully, I wasn't talking about just Korea, i was talking about the idea in general because you never mentioned korea, the way you mentioned it sounded worldwide. But if we are talking about Korea then it's simple why they are changing, it's because they are adopting western ideals. The west can be very persuasive in the east, especially in democratic countries like japan and (S) Korea (I personally don't know what NK is doing).

2

u/HorrorAd7996 Aug 11 '26

Two countries that the west had to put under military dictatorships so they’d adopt western ideals lol.

2

u/lilacnyangi Aug 11 '26

ironically, people shit on korea for their heavyhanded handling of drugs, but korea's culture was actually very interwoven with homeopathy prior to the american takeover and the pressure from america during their war on drugs. you can still see this in its attitudes toward food being seen as medicine, acupuncture and the like.

korea's current extreme views on drugs such as weed actually comes from the bush administration's pressure for the korean government to heavily criminalize them, changing how the korean people view them.

so basically, yeah. i think a lot of the ethnocentric people here would be shocked by how much of their issues with non-western cultures actually come from their own countries.

1

u/ThatDuude_ Aug 11 '26

Haha. They are their own countries now, they make their own decisions, they are big countries now! The west doesn't make them to do this! 😤😂

1

u/HorrorAd7996 Aug 11 '26

You’re not denying that they had military dictatorships because of the US are you?

1

u/ThatDuude_ Aug 11 '26

First: I was joking around Second: We are not going in to this now. Not here, not ever.

2

u/No-Necessary4506 Aug 11 '26

I agree that we cannot view all animals through the same lens since humans are emotional creatures. However, as anyone who has raised pigs or cows would know, they are by no means inferior to dogs in terms of emotional capacity

1

u/ThatDuude_ Aug 11 '26

I ain't gonna argue with that logic. But that's why I don't want to ever raise cows or pigs.

1

u/Striking-water-ant Aug 11 '26

Horses have transported man for thousands of years. Have taken man into battlefields and have stood by man through hundreds of generations.

Yet when it's time for man to name his best friend he says it's a dog??! Those animals are a fraud. One day we'll all wake up from the matrix dogs have put us in...

1

u/IYuShinoda Aug 12 '26

Protecting your dogs is what you fight for

1

u/Striking-water-ant Aug 12 '26

At this rate, we're not getting out of the dog matrix anytime soon...

0

u/ThatDuude_ Aug 11 '26

You really need to do your research on dog warfare buddy.

-1

u/kotonizna Aug 11 '26

what do you think about predators like Hyenas eating their prey alive? What about forced vegetarian dogs and cats?