r/BeAmazed • • Aug 11 '26

Miscellaneous / Others South Korea is closing the dog meat industry.

Post image
25.3k Upvotes

2.5k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

57

u/notschululu Aug 11 '26

The arbitrary Rule of Dogs as Mammals,, not being ok to farm but Dozens of other Mammals being completely fine to slaughter?

-9

u/No_Career_4785 Aug 11 '26

The reason cats and dogs are not that common as food source is simply that carnivores are worse in terms of economy. Why feed pig meat to another animal to eat their meat when you could easily eat the pig meat?

21

u/ninzus161 Aug 11 '26

you could also easily eat the legumes and vegetables instead of the pig

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

[deleted]

13

u/That1one1dude1 Aug 11 '26

Because it’s better to eat everything you can than limit yourself from a pure survival standpoint.

Doesn’t really speak to what is the most optimal today with our mass crops bred over centuries to be ideal for our consumption.

2

u/ninzus161 Aug 11 '26

because we had to before we became an agricultural society. we sort of "evolved" further even and are now in a position where we wouldn't have to rely on meat to get all our nutrients in sufficient density.

-4

u/Plastic-View-9680 Aug 11 '26

Lol. I'm not basing the rest of my life on vegetables and legumes.

If I wanted to be depressed I'd just ruin my life now.

7

u/Jedkea Aug 11 '26

Is your life based on meat now?

-5

u/No_Career_4785 Aug 11 '26

If we get all the nutrients we need from those, we could skip that step as well. But most vegetarian diets can cause malnutrition as we are not herbivores.

10

u/ninzus161 Aug 11 '26

name a nutrient we're not getting from those that doesn't need to be substituted in the majority of animal feed too

1

u/Kinnirasna Aug 12 '26

Some B vitamins?

2

u/ninzus161 Aug 12 '26

they get supplemented in animal feed, only exception are cows

1

u/Kinnirasna Aug 12 '26

Well, It's not being supplemented everywhere I think. They also feed them the discarded flesh of their brethren in some places for supplementation.

1

u/ninzus161 Aug 12 '26

if you don't supplement b12 in chicken feed, the chickens meat will have barely any b12 at all. same with pigs. cows are the only ones that can actually amass enough from natural sources to become a supplier, any other animal gets supplemented the same way a vegan supplements his b12 needs

1

u/Kinnirasna Aug 12 '26

Vitamin C. Primates can't produce it on their own. But other animals can. So, it is not added to thier feed I assume. But vegetables have them. There is no nutrient that falls into that category I guess

-6

u/No_Career_4785 Aug 11 '26

Iron

10

u/zeracine Aug 11 '26

Eat some spinach. Yeah it's not Popeye level of iron, but it's still a fair bit of iron.

8

u/Jedkea Aug 11 '26

What an absolutely wonky thing to say with no evidence 🤦‍♂️

5

u/fatboy93 Aug 11 '26

most vegetarian diets can cause malnutrition as we are not herbivores.

That's an asinine fucking take. As long as you plan your meals, vegetarian meals are no different than meaty meals.

If your entire benchmark is hurr-durr chicken has the lowest glycemic index, and more protein per calorie sure, but you aren't getting any other things.

There are studies that show the health benefits of being vegetarian. As long as you eat mindfully, plan a balanced diet, you shouldn't face any difficulty. I'm saying that as a guy who's generationally vegetarian.

You don't have to take my word for it, but here are some studies:

  1. Comparison of the Health Status of Vegetarians and Omnivores Based on Biochemical Blood Tests, Body Composition Analysis and Quality of Nutrition - https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10346750/

  2. Impact of vegetarian versus non-vegetarian diet on health outcomes in male individuals: A comparative study - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S2212958823000010

  3. Vegetarian and vegan eating - https://www.betterhealth.vic.gov.au/health/healthyliving/vegetarian-and-vegan-eating

-2

u/Hephaistos_Invictus Aug 11 '26 edited Aug 11 '26

Vegan* diets. I've been a vegetarian for 20+ years and never had a b12 deficiency (or any other except for vitamin D). Eggs, yoghurt and cheese give me all I need without killing the animals.

9

u/No_Career_4785 Aug 11 '26

Technically, milk products still kill cows as the cow first needs a child to produce milk and there is not really a large market for male cows besides for food. And I am certain that chickens are also killed the moment they stop producing eggs.

-4

u/Hephaistos_Invictus Aug 11 '26

I have my own chickens that produce eggs. And I get my cheese and yoghurt from my local bio farmer. So at least it's not as horrible as some places. And all the animals involved have a decent to good life.

3

u/TresMil3000 Aug 11 '26

It's not difficult at all to get B12 on a vegan diet. Most plant milks or veggie burgers/sausages are fortified with it. Also 100% of cows and chickens are slaughtered on dairy and egg farms when they are no longer profitable to keep around. Not to mention male cows and chickens which are slaughtered almost immediately since they cannot produce eggs or milk.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 11 '26

[deleted]

-6

u/Old_Adhesiveness7508 Aug 11 '26

Why even eat food when we could eat the feces of other animals?

1

u/GuaSukaStarfruit Aug 11 '26

Why are you not vegan then? Plant protein are best in terms of economy

-2

u/One_Maybe_2460 Aug 11 '26

Let me explain: Islam. Not allowed to eat pig meat. So it’s way more common in the east.

1

u/No_Career_4785 Aug 11 '26

Cow is also an option, as is chicken and sheep.